Plant-based meat vs. Animal Meat: which is healthier and more sustainable?
As you have imagined by now, we do our best to promote a sustainable and healthy lifestyle in Terra Zero. Eating plant-based foods, using natural cosmetics and hygiene products, reusing things instead of throwing away single-use items are all things we believe build on the idea of a more sustainable, equal and healthier world.
Around the issue of plant-based diets and swapping animal meat for plant-based meats, something that holds back many people is that they feel like animal meat is tastier, has a richer nutritional profile and processed vegan meat is not that much more sustainable than animal meat.
To tackle these misconceptions, a new study published in Future Foods concludes that plant-based meat is healthier and more sustainable than animal meat, and, importantly, it provides an easy way for consumers to reduce animal product consumption.
Plant-based meat is better for the environment and has favorable nutritional profiles compared to the animal meat it is designed to replace, according to a new study published in scientific journal Future Foods.
The review involved examining 43 studies related to the healthiness and environmental impacts of plant-based foods as well as literature on consumer attitudes. It concluded that plant-based meat and dairy, although sometimes incorrectly considered “unnatural” or “over-processed” by consumers, offer a healthier and environmentally sustainable solution to animal meat that also takes into account consumers’ eating preferences. Because plant-based meat and other foods are specifically formulated to replicate the taste, texture, and overall eating experience of animal products, they are a much more effective way of reducing the demand for animal-based meat and dairy than simply encouraging people to cook whole plant foods at home.
“Although most consumers correctly view plant-based meat as more nutritionally sound alternatives, their perception as unnatural or overly processed can lead some to incorrectly infer that they are unhealthy and/or harmful in other ways,” the study noted. “This perception may be exacerbated by interests in the conventional animal product industry who seek to cast public doubt on these competing products. Consumers and policymakers must resist the heuristic that animal meat is natural and therefore better, and instead listen to the science, which suggests that plant-based meat can be a sustainable and healthy part of our future protein landscape.”
One study that was part of the review suggested that almost 90 percent of consumers who ate plant-based meat and dairy were meat-eaters, while another study found that plant-based products with a similar taste, texture, and price to processed animal meat had the best chance of replacing meat. Ultimately, the report points out that plant-based meat is intended to displace demand for animal products, not other plant foods, and is more able to do this compared to whole plant foods alone.
Health benefits of plant-based meat
Studies focusing on the healthiness of plant-based products found they tend to have better nutritional profiles compared to animal products, with one paper finding 40 percent of conventional meat products were classified as “less healthy” based on the United Kingdom’s Nutrient Profiling Model, compared to just 14 percent of plant-based alternatives. Others found plant-based meat and dairy were good for weight loss and building muscle mass, and could be used to help people with specific health conditions.
Additionally, one paper found daily consumption of plant-based meat was associated with a 49 percent lower risk of hip fracture. Two separate studies found that, compared to chicken meals, meat made from mycoprotein—a form of single-cell protein derived from fungi—led to a significant reduction in insulin responses, potentially reducing insulin release in overweight people.
The report points out that in many cases the processing of plant-based ingredients can improve nutrition, with one paper highlighting how turning legumes into plant-based meat can enhance people’s ability to digest them. Other papers showed plant-based food had cholesterol-lowering benefits and helped improve gut health.
Notably, food producers may be able to add ingredients such as edible fungi, microalgae, or spirulina to plant-based foods, boosting properties such as amino acids, vitamins B and E, and antioxidants. Future innovations in processing and ingredients are likely to lead to further nutritional improvements.
“These products are able to shift demand away from animal products, and are able to do this far more effectively than whole plant foods, as they hit the key drivers consumers are looking for— taste, price, and convenience,” report author Chris Bryant, PhD, of the University of Bath said in a statement.
Plant-based meat is more sustainable
When it comes to environmental benefits of plant-based meat, the paper also found that plant-based products produced lower levels of greenhouse gas emissions than the animal products they were replacing. One paper found replacing 5 percent of German beef consumption with pea protein would reduce CO2 emissions by eight million metric tons per year. Another found that plant-based burgers were associated with up to 98 percent less greenhouse gas emissions compared to beef burgers.
The report author also found plant-based products required much less agricultural land, used less water, caused less pollution, and required similar or less energy than animal products.
“I have found overwhelming evidence that, as well as being far more sustainable compared to animal products in terms of greenhouse gas emissions, water use and land use, plant-based animal product alternatives also have a wide range of health benefits,” Bryant said.
The report notes that further innovation in processing and formulations have the potential to improve the nutritional profile of plant-based meat products even further, while also improving taste, texture, and price. But additional research funding is imperative to making these potential improvements a reality. “More research funding is now needed to make these improvements a reality, ensuring manufacturers can make products that taste better, are healthier and provide consumers with sustainable options that are more likely to reduce demand for meat,” Bryant said.
All the scientific health evidence , the ethical reasons behind plant-based diets and the fact that is the most impactful way to fight climate change is why we so strongly believe that everyone should at least give an opportunity to the very tasty, nutritionally rich and healthy plant-based meats from the brands moving forwards towards a vegan future!